Skip to the content

Repair or replace an air conditioner: how to compare the two quotes

How to weigh an air conditioner repair quote against a replacement quote: the fault, the age, the parts, your consumer rights and the full installed cost.

Last updated

Start with a diagnosis, not a guess. Have a licensed technician find the fault and put the repair in writing: what failed, the parts, the price and what the repair does not cover. Then set that beside a full installed replacement quote. As a rule of thumb, when a repair costs more than half the price of a new system, replacement is usually the better value.

How to use this guide

  1. Step 1: Get the repair in writing

    A fault found by a technician, with parts and price.

    Go to The repair quote
  2. Step 2: Weigh it up

    Age, history, parts and what a new system would cost.

    Go to Repair or replace
  3. Step 3: Fill in the sheet

    Put the two quotes and the system's history on one page.

    Go to the record

What should a repair quote tell you?

What you suspect and what has failed are often different things. A room that will not cool can come from a blocked filter, a failed part or a refrigerant leak, and each has a different price. A repair quote worth comparing states:

  • the fault the technician found, in their words, and how they found it
  • the parts to be replaced and the labour, with a total that includes GST
  • whether the parts are still available for that model, and how long they take to arrive
  • what the repair does not cover, and anything else the technician saw that is likely to need work
  • the warranty on the repair

Where the fault is low refrigerant, the quote should include finding and repairing the leak. Refrigerant is not used up as a system runs, so a low charge means a leak or a short charge at installation, and the Australian Refrigeration Council (opens in a new tab) says adding refrigerant before a leak is tested and repaired is illegal. A price for adding refrigerant alone is not a repair.

To describe the fault well when you book, see the guide to an air conditioner that is not cooling.

When is an air conditioner worth repairing, and when replacing?

An air conditioner usually lasts 10 to 15 years, and a well-kept one can go longer. Age alone does not decide it. These are the things we weigh:

What points to a repair and what points to a replacement
What you knowWhat it points to
The system is under about 10 years old and this is its first real faultRepair, in most cases.
The repair costs more than half the price of a new systemReplacement is usually the better value.
It has needed several repairs in the last few yearsUsually replacement. Repeated faults are a sign that a system is near the end of its life.
It is 10 to 15 years old or more, and the fault is a major partReplacement, unless the repair is small.
Parts for the model are no longer availableReplacement.
It is still under warranty, or failed early for its ageA claim first. See the section on warranty and consumer guarantees.
The system has not suited the room: too big, too small or too noisyReplacement is the chance to fix that. A repair restores what you had.

The rule of thumb is a guide. The two written quotes and the condition of the system decide your case, and a technician who has seen the unit is the person to ask how much life is left in it.

Is it still under warranty or a consumer guarantee?

Check this before you pay for a repair. Find the purchase date, the installer's invoice and the warranty papers. Two separate protections can apply:

There is no set rule for how long a product should last. The ACCC lists the questions to ask, including how old the product is and how long similar products normally last. Where a problem is major, the consumer can choose a refund or a replacement (opens in a new tab). Where it is minor, the business must fix it with at least a free repair. The business that sold the system is the one responsible for resolving it. That is as at November 2026.

The guide to warranties, workmanship and consumer guarantees covers this in full.

What should the replacement quote include?

Compare the repair with the whole replacement job, not the price of a unit in a shop. A full quote covers the equipment, the installation, any electrical work, the removal of the old system and the making good. A replacement into the same positions usually costs less than a first installation.

As at November 2026, our general guide is $2,000 to $4,000 for a basic residential split system, installed, and from $7,000 to $15,000 or more for a ducted system, depending on the size of the home and the zoning. Your quote is the price. The guide to comparing air conditioning installation quotes lists what a complete quote states.

Count the disruption as well: the wait for a part on one side, and the installation on the other. As a guide, a standard split system installation takes us 4 to 6 hours and a ducted system 1 to 3 days, depending on the home.

What about running costs?

New models are more efficient than the ones they replace, so a new system should use less electricity for the same comfort. How much less depends on the two models, your tariff and how many hours it runs, and nobody can promise you a figure. Work it out from the energy label: the guide to air conditioner kW output and electricity usage has the method and a worksheet.

Is there a discount for replacing an old system?

In Victoria, the Victorian Energy Upgrades (opens in a new tab) program offers a discount on an approved reverse cycle air conditioner, and the amount depends on what is being replaced. The upgrade has to go through an accredited provider, or an installer working with one, and the program recommends contacting a provider before you buy, because a discount is typically not applied afterwards. That is as at November 2026. The guide to rebates in an air conditioning quote has the questions to ask.

Does the refrigerant phase-down mean I have to replace it?

No. The Australian Government's HFC phase-down (opens in a new tab) reduces bulk imports of the gas. It says existing equipment is not affected and that consumers do not have to replace it. If a quote says your system has to go because of its refrigerant, ask for the reason in writing. Whether a repair is practical is a separate question from the phase-down.

Some older systems run on R22, an earlier refrigerant with its own rules. As at June 2023, the Australian Refrigeration Council (opens in a new tab) says existing units can still be serviced with it, that there is no need to change a system that is in good working order, that imports end entirely on 1 January 2030, and that spare parts may become harder to find.

Repair or replace comparison sheet

Repair or replace comparison

Fill in what you know, then copy it or print it.

Your answers stay on this open page. They are not saved or sent. Copy or print them before you leave.

The system

Type of system
Still under the maker's warranty

Its history

The repair quote

Parts available for this model

The replacement quote

The comparison

Who to call

We repair, service and replace air conditioners for homes and businesses in Bairnsdale and East Gippsland, so we can quote both sides of this decision. Our air conditioning repairs page explains how to book a repair visit and what to have ready, and our air conditioning page covers new systems.

Sources (13)

Want a technician to look at it?

Call ABL or send an enquiry. Have your notes ready: the brand, the model and what the unit is doing.

Filled in the record? Copy or print it first: it is not sent with a call or an enquiry.