Flake ice, crushed block ice or slurry: choosing ice for the catch
How flake ice, crushed block ice and slurry compare on a fishing vessel for chilling, handling and storage, and which suits which job, with a matrix.
Last updated
Neither flake ice nor crushed block ice is the better ice for every boat. Weight for weight they hold the same cooling, so the choice is about handling. Flake ice packs around fish, marks them least and chills them faster, but it takes more room per tonne and packs hard in storage after a couple of days. Crushed block ice takes less room and keeps longest when the blocks are carried whole and crushed as needed, but coarse pieces bruise fish and cool them more slowly. Slurry chills fastest of all, but it needs its own equipment and a limit on how long fish stay in it.
How to use this guide
Is flake ice better than crushed block ice?
Not for the amount you need. Equal weights of ice have equal cooling capacity, whatever form they take, so a tonne of flake does the same cooling as a tonne of crushed block. Equal volumes are different: a cubic metre of flake ice holds far less ice, and far less cooling, than a cubic metre of crushed block.
Speed and damage are where they differ. Small, smooth flakes sit close against the fish, melt faster and chill it faster. Coarse lumps of crushed block leave gaps, chill more slowly and can mark and bruise the fish. Crushed fine, block ice closes much of that gap, so the question to ask first is what you need the ice to do.
How flake, crushed block and slurry compare
| Compare | Flake ice | Crushed block ice | Slurry |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Thin, dry flakes about 2 to 3 mm thick, scraped off a frozen drum, ready to use. | Blocks frozen in cans ashore, crushed before use. | Small ice crystals in seawater or brine that can be pumped. Made by a slurry machine, or by mixing ice with seawater. |
| Chilling speed | Fast, because it packs closely around the fish. | Slower, unless crushed fine. Large lumps leave air gaps. | Fastest. It surrounds every fish. |
| Marks on fish | The least of the solid forms. | Coarse pieces can mark and bruise. | Little physical damage, but salt uptake and partial freezing if fish stay too long or it runs too cold. |
| Space for a tonne | About 2.2 to 2.3 cubic metres. | About 1.4 to 1.5 cubic metres. | Held in tanks, with water as part of the mix. |
| Keeping in store | Workable for about two days, then packs hard. Melts faster in store. | Keeps longest as whole blocks. Stored crushed, it clumps within a day. | Made close to use. Crystals separate if left to stand. |
| Where it is made | On board, by a flake ice machine, or bought ashore. | Ashore, then carried whole and crushed on board. | On board, by a slurry machine with a tank and pumps, or mixed in tubs. |
| Handling | Drops from a deck machine straight into the hold, or shovelled. | Needs a crusher. A hammer leaves pieces too big to chill well. | Pumped by hose to where it is needed. |
Flake ice takes more power to make per tonne than block ice, because the machine runs colder, but crushing adds labour and cost to block ice, so the costs end up closer than they first look. Making ice on board saves waiting for ice and avoids carrying ice out on a trip that comes back light, but the machine and its storage take space and power. Compare the true cost of making ice at sea with buying it ashore.
Which ice suits which job?
- Flake ice is usually the better choice when you make ice on board and stow fresh catch straight away, when marks on the fish cost you at market, and when the machine can drop ice straight into the hold. It is the most common ice machine on small fishing vessels.
- Crushed block ice is usually the better choice when you buy ice ashore for a longer trip and hold space is tight, and you can carry the blocks whole and crush them finely with a mechanical crusher as you go.
- Slurry is usually the better choice for a fast first chill of small fish or pelagic fish, landed in tubs or moved on to solid ice for the rest of the trip, on a vessel with the space, power and crew to run the whole system.
How much ice the trip needs is its own question: the guide to building an ice-demand brief for a fishing trip works it out. Ratios depend on the water and air temperatures, the hold's insulation, the fish and the length of the trip, and the ice left at landing is the check.
Slurry ice: what to settle before an assessment
Slurry is a system, not just a form of ice. A slurry machine makes ice crystals from seawater or brine into an insulated tank with an agitator, and pumps carry it to the fish. If any part is too small, such as the tank, the whole system falls short when the catch comes in. Some boats make a simpler slurry by mixing flake or crushed ice with seawater in tubs, and research results for one do not carry over to the other. In one Australian trial on sardines, machine-made slurry chilled the fish to 2°C in about 9 minutes against 30 minutes for ice mixed with water, yet the fish sold for the same price.
The risks are partial freezing, salt uptake and leaving fish in too long. Fish held much below about minus 1°C can dull and toughen. In UK trials, flat fish and Nephrops, a scampi-like shellfish, took up more salt than the other fish tested. How long is safe depends on the species and how the fish are prepared, and the research differs: under two hours for tropical reef fish in one Australian study, no more than a day for gutted haddock in an Icelandic study before moving it to solid ice, and two to four hours for gutted fish in a US guide. A common practice is slurry for the first chill and solid ice for the hold. Little research covers Victorian species, so a trial on your own catch is worth more than any of these figures.
Before you ask a supplier about a slurry system, settle:
- which species, whole or gutted, and how long they would sit in slurry before stowing
- what holds the fish after the first chill, and for how long
- where the tank, pumps and slurry machine would go, and what power they need
- the clean seawater supply, and how the salt strength and temperature are controlled
- who checks the result with your buyer or processor before you commit
Flake ice made from seawater
Many vessel flake machines make ice from seawater. It can be made at sea without carrying fresh water, and it runs a little colder, but it is softer, and fish in it can partly freeze or take up salt, thin-skinned fish most of all. Food Standards Australia New Zealand's guide to the seafood standard (opens in a new tab) says ice made on board comes from clean seawater once the vessel is clear of the harbour, and that seawater ice temperature should be monitored. The guide to freshwater or seawater ice for an onboard system covers that choice in full.
Handling and storing ice on board
- Ice goes under, around and on top of the fish, so each fish touches ice rather than other fish. In bulk, start with a layer about 10 to 15 cm deep and finish with the same on top. In boxes, about 5 cm top and bottom.
- Put extra ice where heat gets in, against the engine room bulkhead and the hull sides.
- Fine, soft ice goes against the fish. Coarser crushed ice is better kept to the top layer, placed with care.
- Let meltwater drain away. It carries slime and bacteria, and fish should not sit in it.
- Keep unused ice in its own pen, away from fish and ice that has been in contact with fish.
- Work stored flake ice with a shovel now and then, so it does not pack solid.
- Throw out unused ice at the end of each trip and wash and sanitise the hold. Ice can look clean and still carry spoilage bacteria.
No ice form makes poor fish good again. Spoilage only slows, and how long chilled fish keep varies by species from a few days to a few weeks, so treat any shelf life you are quoted as a figure for one species in one trial.
Ice form decision matrix
Next step
ABL supplies, installs and services ice machines on commercial fishing vessels: saltwater flake machines, and freshwater flake and cube machines. Our marine ice machines page explains how to get in touch. If you have settled on making ice on board, the guide to retrofitting an ice machine on a fishing boat: the survey pack covers what an installer needs, and the guide to the marine ice machine maintenance schedule and service log covers keeping the machine making clean ice.
Sources (19)
Checked on 20 November 2026
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries (1992), chapter 2: the nature and properties of ice (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries (1992), chapter 3: the quantity of ice required (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries (1992), chapter 5: ice machines (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries (1992), chapter 6: ice plants and storage (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries (1992), chapter 8: chilling fish at sea (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 436, The use of ice on small fishing vessels (2003), chapter 1: fish spoilage and chilling (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 436, The use of ice on small fishing vessels (2003), chapter 2: the manufacture of ice (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 436, The use of ice on small fishing vessels (2003), chapter 3: planning (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 436, The use of ice on small fishing vessels (2003), chapter 4: the use of ice on board (opens in a new tab)
- Torry Advisory Note 21, Which kind of ice is best?, FAO electronic edition (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Circular 735, Planning and engineering data 1: fresh fish handling (1981), ice (opens in a new tab)
- Seafish Report SR558, Further trials of the pumpable icing of fish (2004) (opens in a new tab)
- Seafish and Seafood Scotland: the good practice guide for demersal fishermen (opens in a new tab)
- Matís report 54-10, Optimised chilling protocols for fresh fish (2010) (opens in a new tab)
- FRDC and Australian Seafood CRC project 2008/717, Improving quality of Australian sardines through flow-ice technology (2009) (opens in a new tab)
- FRDC project 89/93, Development of the tropical reef fish fishery: handling methods for high quality chilled fish (opens in a new tab)
- Gulf of Maine Research Institute: slurry ice and best practices for chilling fish (opens in a new tab)
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand: Safe Seafood Australia, a guide to Standard 4.2.1, second edition (opens in a new tab)
- ABL Refrigeration: marine ice machines (opens in a new tab) ABL's own page.
Related pages
- Marine ice machines
How to get in touch with ABL about an ice machine for a vessel.
- Freshwater or seawater ice for an onboard system
Seawater or fresh water for the ice your machine makes.
- Building an ice-demand brief for a fishing trip
How much ice a trip needs.
Thinking about making ice on board?
Call ABL with your decision matrix in front of you, or send it with an enquiry.
Filled in the record? Copy or print it first: it is not sent with a call or an enquiry.
