Freshwater or seawater ice for a fishing boat's ice machine
How freshwater and seawater ice machines differ on a fishing boat: the water supply, the machine model, the catch and food safety, with a comparison sheet.
Last updated
A seawater ice machine can keep making ice for as long as the boat is in clean water, so it suits longer trips and boats that cannot carry much fresh water. Freshwater ice is more predictable on the catch, and easier on the machine, but every kilogram of it is a kilogram of fresh water the boat has to carry, make or take on in port. The choice turns on your water supply, your catch and the exact machine model, in that order.
How to use this guide
Step 3: Fill in the comparison sheet
With the answers from the supplier and your buyer.
Go to the record
How is seawater ice different from freshwater ice?
Freshwater ice melts at 0°C, so fish packed in it settle at about 0°C and go no lower. The ice keeps its own temperature in check.
Seawater ice has no fixed melting point, because the salt is not spread evenly through it. Straight from the machine it can be several degrees below zero, and it melts at about minus 1.5 to minus 2°C, warming toward 0°C as the salty meltwater drains away. It is softer than freshwater ice and can look wet even when it is cold. That is why it chills a little colder, and why fish left in it can partly freeze or take up salt, thin-skinned fish most of all.
Weight for weight, both do about the same cooling. For the form of the ice, flake or crushed block or slurry, see the guide to flake ice or crushed block ice.
Where will the water for the ice come from?
Ice is frozen water, so a machine that makes a tonne of ice a day uses about a tonne, or 1,000 litres, of water a day to do it. Ask these questions about your own operation before you compare machines:
| Question | Freshwater machine | Seawater machine |
|---|---|---|
| Where does the water come from? | The boat's fresh water tanks, a watermaker, or a shore supply in port. | An intake through the hull, with a seacock, a strainer and a pump. |
| When can it make ice for the catch? | Wherever it has water fit to drink, in port or at sea, for as long as the fresh water lasts. | Once the boat is clear of the harbour and in clean water. |
| What limits it on a long trip? | Tank space, or what the watermaker can produce, against everything else the crew uses water for. | Little. The machine and the intake have to be built for seawater. |
| What about the ice for the start of the trip? | It can be made in port before you leave. | It comes from shore, or, where the model can also freeze fresh water, from fresh water in port. |
| What does the water need? | Water fit to drink, from tanks kept clean and covered. Makers set limits on pressure and filtering. | Clean seawater, drawn well away from runoff, sewage and waste water, through a pump used only for that job. |
A watermaker can supply a freshwater machine at sea, but makers do not agree on whether its water suits every machine as it comes. One maker says watermaker water comes close to pure feed water; another says water straight from a reverse osmosis system needs treating before it goes into its flaker. Ask the maker of the exact ice machine, in writing.
Is a seawater-cooled ice machine a seawater ice machine?
Not necessarily. Many ice machines on fishing boats use two separate kinds of water, and data sheets often mention both:
- The water it freezes. This becomes the ice, and it is either fresh water or seawater.
- The water that cools its condenser. This carries the heat away and goes back overboard. On a boat it is usually seawater, whichever water the machine freezes.
Several makers build machines that freeze fresh water and are cooled by seawater, so "seawater-cooled" on a data sheet tells you nothing about which ice it makes. The cooling flow is also far bigger than the water frozen: one seawater flake machine's data sheet gives about 11,200 litres an hour through the condenser to make about 125 kg of ice an hour. Each circuit has its own pipework in materials that suit seawater, and some makers ask for a separate intake through the hull for each pump. Ask the supplier to name both waters for the model you are quoted.
Can a freshwater ice machine make seawater ice?
Only if its maker says that model can. Do not assume it. Makers fall into three groups:
| What the maker does | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| Builds the model for fresh water only | At least one maker says plainly that seawater damages its freshwater machines and voids the warranty. These cannot be switched. |
| Builds a fresh water version and a seawater version of the same model | The seawater version runs colder and uses parts that resist corrosion. Two makers' data sheets show their seawater versions making about 15 to 30 per cent less ice than the freshwater versions of the same models. |
| Sells a separate seawater model with more refrigeration | Output can come close to the freshwater model, at the cost of a bigger refrigeration unit and more power. |
Seawater freezes at a lower temperature than fresh water, so a machine making seawater ice has to run its freezing surface colder, which takes more refrigeration. Machines built for seawater usually cost more to buy and to run. Warranty terms can differ too: one maker's warranty on the evaporator, the part that freezes the ice, is far shorter on its seawater units than on its freshwater ones. The manual and the data sheet for the exact model decide what it can do, at what output and under what warranty.
What does seawater ice mean for the catch?
Neither ice is better for every catch. Seawater ice chills a little colder. Because its temperature varies, fish packed in it for long can partly freeze, and some species take up salt. Freshwater ice holds the fish at about 0°C without that risk.
If you use seawater ice, keep a check on temperatures. Food Standards Australia New Zealand's guide to the seafood standard (opens in a new tab) says the temperature should be monitored when seawater ice is used, because salt water has a lower freezing point than fresh water and could damage fish, making them unsuitable. The guide is the second edition of April 2006, still the one Food Standards lists as at November 2026.
Whether seawater ice suits your species, how long the fish sit in it and what your buyers accept are questions about your catch handling, not about the machine. Put them to whoever advises you on that: your buyer, your processor or a seafood quality adviser.
What do the food safety rules say about ice on a fishing boat?
Ice that touches seafood has to be safe. Food Standards Australia New Zealand's guide to the seafood standard (opens in a new tab) describes ice in contact with stored seafood as made from potable water, obtained from an approved supplier or, if made on board, made from clean seawater once the vessel is clear of the harbour and sailing in clean water. It also asks for water storage tanks to be kept clean and covered.
In Victoria, Safe Food Victoria (opens in a new tab) licenses wildcatch seafood businesses. It inspects harvesting vessels before operations begin, and a wildcatch business must meet the Food Standards Code. As at November 2026, its wildcatch page says nothing specific about ice machines, so the seafood standard and its guide are where the ice wording comes from.
Which is the better choice for your boat?
| Option | Usually the better choice when |
|---|---|
| A seawater ice machine | Trips are long enough that ice has to be made at sea, fresh water on board is short, the catch handles seawater ice well, and the boat has room and power for a machine built for seawater. |
| A freshwater ice machine | The catch is delicate, thin-skinned or takes up salt, the boat can carry or make enough fresh water, or most of the ice is made in port before the trip. |
| Ice loaded in port, with no machine | Trips are short enough that ice loaded at the start lasts the trip. The guide to how much ice a fishing trip needs works that out. |
Where two of these fit, the water supply usually settles it. A boat that cannot carry or make a tonne of fresh water for every tonne of ice it needs at sea is looking at seawater ice, and the catch handling has to be set up for it.
Freshwater or seawater comparison sheet
Next step
We supply, install, service and repair saltwater flake machines, which make ice from seawater, and freshwater machines that make flake or cubed ice, on commercial fishing vessels. We help you choose the right machine for your catch and trip length when we quote, and as at November 2026 the quote is free. We work on boats in port at Lakes Entrance, Paynesville, Metung and Bairnsdale. Our marine ice machines page explains how to enquire. Bring the comparison sheet and the trip ice worksheet. If the boat holds a certificate of survey, ask your accredited marine surveyor or AMSA before a new intake or a machine goes aboard. The guide to retrofitting an ice machine on a fishing boat covers what to gather.
Sources (21)
Checked on 20 November 2026
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 436: chapter 2, forms of ice and ice-making on board (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries: chapter 5, ice-making machines (opens in a new tab)
- FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 331, Ice in fisheries: chapter 2, nature and properties of ice (opens in a new tab)
- Torry Advisory Note 21, Which kind of ice is best? (FAO edition) (opens in a new tab)
- Seafish: good practice guide for demersal fishermen (opens in a new tab)
- FRDC project 89/93: handling methods for high quality chilled tropical reef fish (opens in a new tab)
- Howe: making ice at sea (opens in a new tab)
- Howe: shipboard flake ice machines data sheet (opens in a new tab)
- Howe: RL flake ice machine installation manual (opens in a new tab)
- JBT Marel: MAJA RVE-2S flake ice machines for fresh water and seawater (opens in a new tab)
- JBT Marel: MAJA ice machines catalogue (opens in a new tab)
- ZIEGRA: trawler ice machines for fresh and salt water (opens in a new tab)
- ZIEGRA: trawler ice machines for fresh water (opens in a new tab)
- Geneglace: on-board models for fresh and sea water (opens in a new tab)
- Dometic: EI540D marine ice maker installation and operation manual (opens in a new tab)
- Scotsman: MAR marine flaker service manual (opens in a new tab)
- Odimer: SFM30 seawater flake ice machine technical sheet (opens in a new tab)
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand: Safe Seafood Australia, a guide to Standard 4.2.1 (opens in a new tab)
- Safe Food Victoria: wildcatch licence (opens in a new tab)
- Marine Order 503 (Certificates of survey, national law) 2026, made 10 November 2026, in force from 1 December 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- ABL Refrigeration: marine ice machines (opens in a new tab) ABL's own page.
Related pages
- Marine ice machines for commercial fishing vessels
Supply, installation, servicing and repairs, and how to enquire.
- How much ice a fishing trip needs: building the ice brief
Work out how much ice the boat needs at sea.
- Flake ice, crushed block ice or slurry: choosing ice for the catch
How each form of ice packs, stores and chills.
Choosing an ice machine for your boat?
Bring the comparison sheet and your trip figures. We supply and fit saltwater and freshwater ice machines on fishing vessels in port.
Filled in the record? Copy or print it first: it is not sent with a call or an enquiry.
