Skip to the content

Heat recovery from dairy refrigeration: does it fit your hot water use?

How dairy refrigeration heat recovery pre-heats wash water, when the heat is there and when you need it, what has to fit, and what to measure first.

Last updated

Heat recovery takes heat your milk refrigeration would otherwise throw away at the condenser, and uses it to pre-heat water for washing the plant and the vat. It pre-heats rather than heats: the pre-heat tank typically reaches about 40 to 45°C, and your water heater still lifts the water to wash temperature. On a shed that heats its water with electric elements, it typically cuts the cost of heating that water by around 40 per cent. Whether it is worth fitting depends on how much hot water you use, when the refrigeration runs compared with when you wash, the quality of your water and the systems you already have.

How to use this guide

  1. Step 1: Map the timing

    When your refrigeration makes heat, and when the shed washes.

    Go to Timing
  2. Step 2: Fill in the worksheet

    Your hot water use, your refrigeration and your water.

    Go to the record
  3. Step 3: Call

    Talk it through with the worksheet in front of you.

    Call (03) 5153 2650

How does heat recovery work on a dairy?

Refrigeration takes heat out of the milk and gets rid of it at the condenser, together with the heat of the compressor's own work. A heat recovery unit sits in the refrigeration circuit between the compressor and the condenser and passes some of that heat into water first. The condenser stays in the circuit and gets rid of whatever the water does not take. There are three usual arrangements:

The three usual heat recovery arrangements
ArrangementHow it worksWater it suits
Brazed plate heat exchanger with a pumpHot refrigerant from the compressor passes through a small plate heat exchanger, and a pump circulates water from a pre-heat tank through the other side.Good-quality water.
The same, with advanced controlsControls turn the condenser fan off and regulate the water flow, which recovers more heat and warms the water by about 5 to 10°C more.Good-quality water.
Copper coil in the tankHot refrigerant runs through copper tubing inside the pre-heat tank on its way to the condenser. No water is pumped.Can use lower-quality water.

How much heat is on offer depends on the refrigeration: how much milk it cools, from what temperature, and how long it runs. A shed with good pre-cooling sends less heat to the refrigeration, and so has less to recover. That is still the right way round, because pre-cooling with water is the cheapest cooling in the shed, as the guide to one-stage or two-stage milk pre-cooling explains.

When is the heat there, and when do you need hot water?

Heat recovery makes heat only while the refrigeration runs. The shed uses most of its hot water for the plant wash after each milking and the vat wash after each pick-up. A pre-heat tank bridges the gap, so the timing of the two decides how big the tank needs to be and how much of the heat is used.

When each kind of refrigeration makes heat
RefrigerationWhen it makes heatWhat that means for hot water
Direct expansion vatDuring milking and for a while after, as it brings the milk down, then in short runs to hold it.Most of the heat comes during and just after milking, so the tank warms through milking, around the time of the wash that follows it.
Glycol chiller that cools on demandDuring milking, at a high rate for a short time.A lot of heat in a short time, so the tank has to be big enough to take it.
Ice bank or chilled-water storeWhile the store is built, which is often overnight.The heat arrives when nobody is washing, so it has to wait in the tank until the next wash.

Water that waits loses heat, and water that waits warm is a hygiene risk, so the tank is sized for the heat and the use, not as large as possible.

What has to fit with the systems you have?

What a heat recovery unit has to fit with
CheckWhy it matters
Your refrigerationWhich unit it is, its size and how long it runs set the heat on offer. The unit goes into the refrigerant circuit, which is licensed refrigeration work.
Your waterBore water harder than about 70 ppm scales the heat transfer surfaces and cuts their performance, and hard water should not go through a brazed plate exchanger carrying hot refrigerant, which clogs with calcium salts. A copper coil in the tank can use lower-quality water. Iron in bore water builds up on equipment too. A water test settles it.
Your water heaterHeat recovery feeds pre-heated water to the heater, which still lifts it to wash temperature. The heater type, its tank and its set temperature decide how the two connect.
Your cleaning routineHow many washes a day, and how much hot water each takes. A cold-water rinse, or a wash system that recycles detergent, cuts the energy spent heating water, and so the value of recovered heat.
How you heat water nowRecovered heat replaces some of the energy your heater uses. Where that energy is already cheap, such as from your own solar, the gain is smaller.
Space and distanceRoom for a pre-heat tank, and how far apart the refrigeration and the water heater are.

Is a warm pre-heat tank a hygiene risk?

It can be. A pre-heat tank typically sits at about 40 to 45°C, a good temperature for the growth of Legionella bacteria, which can cause pneumonia when water droplets carrying them are breathed in. The tank has to be kept clean and emptied daily, so the design needs to make that easy, and the water heater then lifts the water to its full wash temperature. Ask any proposal how it does both.

Wash water and milk cooling: two jobs, joined but separate

Heat recovery joins two systems with different duties. The refrigeration has to get the milk cold in time at every milking. The hot water system has to give every wash its full temperature. A sound design lets each do its job without depending on the other:

  • the condenser stays in the circuit and gets rid of the heat whenever the water is already hot, so milk cooling does not depend on anyone using hot water
  • the water heater is still able to heat a whole wash on its own, so a day with little recovered heat, or a refrigeration fault, still gives a full-temperature wash
  • the refrigeration is sized for the milk, not for the hot water

Which cooling system you have, or choose, changes how much heat there is to recover and when. The guide to comparing milk-vat refrigeration and stored-cooling systems covers that choice.

In one Victorian case study, a dairy at Tatura that uses more than 1,000 litres of hot water a day to clean its vat and plant fitted a glycol chiller with a heat recovery unit. The unit heats water to 55°C from the chiller's heat, and the electric hot water service lifts it from there to the temperature the wash needs.

What needs measuring before a cost assessment?

A heat recovery assessment is only as good as the figures it starts from. An assessment that states its assumptions, such as the litres a day, the water temperatures in and out, the tariff and the heat lost from the tank, is one you can check against your own shed.

Figures for a heat recovery assessment
FigureHow to get it
Hot water used a day, and for each washThe volume of each hot wash, times the washes a day, at mid-lactation. The wash system settings or your milking machine fitter can tell you the volume of each wash.
When each wash happensYour milking and pick-up routine.
The temperature the wash needsYour water heater's set temperature and your wash routine.
How long the refrigeration runs, and whenNote when the vat unit starts and stops over one day, from where you stand. A technician can measure it more closely.
Your refrigeration unitThe brand and model from its nameplate.
Hardness and iron in the waterA water test of the supply you heat.
What heating water costs nowYour heater type, your tariff, and your bills.
Space and distancesWhere a pre-heat tank could go, and how far it is from the refrigeration and the heater.

Heat and hot water worksheet

Heat and hot water worksheet

Fill in what you know, then copy it or print it. Write "not known" for anything that would need measuring.

Your answers stay on this open page. They are not saved or sent. Copy or print them before you leave.

Hot water use

Water heater
Water source for hot water
Water test
A cold-water rinse or detergent recycling is in use

The refrigeration

Cooling system
Heat recovery now

Energy

Room for a pre-heat tank near the water heater

Plans

Who does which part?

A heat recovery unit goes into the refrigeration circuit, and work that involves handling a scheduled refrigerant needs a technician licensed by the Australian Refrigeration Council (opens in a new tab). Electrical work, such as controls and pumps, is for a licensed electrician.

The water connections change your heated water service. Victoria's Plumbing Regulations 2018 (opens in a new tab) class that as water supply work, done by a licensed or registered plumber, except work on piped non-drinking water for agricultural purposes that no water provider supplies. Ask who will do the water connections before work starts, and give them your water heater's details.

ABL's refrigeration work includes milk vat cooling and bulk milk storage. Our farm and dairy refrigeration page explains how to book. Have your worksheet in front of you when you call.