Skip to the content

Direct expansion or stored cooling for milk: how to compare them

How direct expansion vats, ice banks, glycol chillers and chilled-water stores compare on power at milking, running cost and upkeep, with a worksheet.

Last updated

Direct expansion cools milk with refrigerant running through the vat's own jacket, making the cold as it is needed, during and just after milking. An ice bank, or a store of chilled water or glycol, makes the cold beforehand and passes it to the milk through a plate cooler. Direct expansion is simpler and uses less energy overall, so stored cooling earns its place where the power supply cannot carry the load at milking time, or where power at other times is cheap enough to cover the extra energy it uses.

How to use this guide

  1. Step 1: See the load

    How the heat in a milking becomes a peak on your power supply.

    Go to Cooling load
  2. Step 2: Fill in the worksheet

    Your milk, your milking time, your power and your tariff.

    Go to the record
  3. Step 3: Call

    Talk the options through with the worksheet in front of you.

    Call (03) 5153 2650

How do direct expansion and stored cooling work?

  • Direct expansion (DX): refrigerant expands in the jacket on the inside surfaces of the vat and takes heat straight from the milk, and a compressor and condenser outside get rid of it. The cold is made when it is needed, so the compressor has to be big enough for the peak load during and just after milking. It is the most common arrangement on Australian dairies.
  • Ice bank: a refrigeration unit builds ice on coils in a tank of water, usually overnight or while power is cheaper. During milking, water chilled by the ice runs through a plate cooler, and the warmed water goes back over the ice to be cooled again. Older ice bank vats carry the ice in a jacket around the milk. DX vats often replace them, because they hold more milk in the same space.
  • Chilled water or glycol store: refrigeration chills water to about 1°C, or a glycol mix to below 0°C, ahead of time, and holds it in an insulated tank. During milking it cools the milk through a plate cooler after the pre-cooler.
  • Glycol chiller on demand, sold as instant or snap chilling: a refrigeration unit chills a small volume of food-grade glycol mix during milking and runs it through a plate cooler, so the milk can reach the vat close to storage temperature. Nothing is stored, so the chiller has to be big enough for the milk as it flows.

With an ice bank or a store, the vat usually keeps a smaller refrigeration unit of its own to finish the cooling and hold the milk until pick-up. Some glycol chillers also cool the vat between milkings. How cold the milk is before any of this starts depends on the pre-cooler, covered in the guide to one-stage or two-stage milk pre-cooling.

How do the options compare?

Direct expansion, stored cooling and on-demand glycol compared
What you are comparingDirect expansion vatIce bank or chilled-water storeGlycol chiller on demand
When it draws powerDuring and just after milking, often at the peak tariff.While the store is built, which can be overnight, off-peak or while solar is generating.During milking, at a high rate for a short time.
Load on the supply at milkingThe whole cooling load, from a compressor sized for the peak.Pumps move the stored cold, and the vat unit can be smaller.A much larger compressor than an in-vat system needs, running while the milk flows.
Energy used overallLess than a store. The cold goes straight into the milk.More. Stored cold leaks to the surroundings, and the refrigeration works less efficiently making ice or very cold fluid.No storage losses, but it draws all its power during milking, often at the peak tariff, so it can cost more to run.
Milk temperature into the vatWhatever the pre-cooler gives. The vat does the rest.Close to storage temperature with ice water. A little above the store temperature with chilled water.Close to storage temperature.
SpaceNo extra tank.An insulated tank. An ice bank takes less room than chilled water, and a chilled-water store may need to hold about a full day of milking.Compact.
Cost to buyLower than the stored options.Higher than direct expansion. An old vat can sometimes be reused as the chilled-water or glycol tank.A big capital item, mostly for the large compressor.
UpkeepA pressurised refrigeration system, serviced by a licensed technician.Ice banks can need more maintenance than other systems.The chiller, the glycol and its pumps, and the plate cooler.

No arrangement wins on every farm. Direct expansion is the usual choice where the supply to the shed is big enough and reliable. Stored cooling probably does not pay unless it solves another problem, such as a grid connection that cannot carry a bigger vat unit on an expanding farm, and its sums improve for larger herds, above about 15,000 litres a day, though each farm decides it on its own figures. An on-demand glycol chiller buys fast cooling with a large load at milking time.

How much cooling does a milking need?

The cooling load is the heat in the milk that the refrigeration has to take out, and the time it has to do it in. A designer works it out from the litres in a milking, how warm the milk is after the pre-cooler, the storage temperature and how long the milking lasts. Here is the sum for one example milking:

Working out the cooling load for one example milking
StepExample
Milk in the milking6,000 litres over a milking of two and a half hours.
Temperature drop the refrigeration providesFrom 15°C after the pre-cooler down to 4°C: 11 degrees.
Heat to take outAbout 74 kWh: 6,000 litres, times 1.03 kg a litre, times 3.93 kJ per kg per degree, times 11 degrees, divided by 3,600.
Time to take it outThe milking plus half an hour: 3 hours.
Cooling duty74 kWh over 3 hours: about 25 kW of cooling.
Electrical powerAbout 8 kW, where the refrigeration moves 3 units of heat for each unit of electricity it uses.

Three things follow from it. Every degree the pre-cooler takes off is heat the refrigeration does not have to remove. A shorter milking with the same milk pushes the same heat into fewer hours, so the duty and the power at milking time go up. And the refrigeration moves less heat for each unit of electricity as the air around an air-cooled condenser gets hotter, so a hot afternoon milking asks the most of it. With direct expansion that peak lands on your supply during milking. With a store, it is spread over the hours the store is built.

This example cools to 4°C and allows half an hour after the last cups come off. Those two are choices, not rules: your target and your time come from your processor and your food safety program, and the guide to one-stage or two-stage milk pre-cooling sets out the Australian regime. The example is a way of seeing the sum, not a size for your shed. Your own volume, your summer pre-cooling and your milking time change every line of it.

Will your power supply carry it at milking time?

Direct expansion and on-demand chilling both put their load on the supply during milking, on top of the vacuum pump, the milk pump and anything else running then. On some farms, smaller sheds especially, the supply cannot carry a bigger compressor. Before you compare systems, find out:

  • whether the shed is on single-phase or three-phase power
  • whether the transformer and the line to the shed have room for more load
  • whether a bigger load at milking would add peak or demand charges to your bill
  • which other loads could run outside milking time, such as effluent irrigation

A licensed electrician can tell you what the supply can carry, and does any work on it. Where the supply is the limit, stored cooling is the main way around it: the refrigeration builds the store while the shed's other loads are off, and milking draws on what is stored, so the shed leans less on the grid at milking time. Where the supply is both big enough and reliable, that advantage counts for less, and direct expansion uses less energy.

What drives the cost to buy and to run?

What drives the cost of each arrangement
CostWhat drives it
Buying itThe compressor size, set by the peak load. For a store, the tank, its insulation, the ice bank or glycol, a second plate pack, pumps and controls. For an on-demand chiller, the large compressor. And any upgrade to the power supply.
Running itThe energy used overall, and the tariff in force when that energy is drawn. Stored cooling saves money only where power at the time the store is built is cheap enough to cover the extra energy it uses, so a change of tariff can change the answer.
SolarA store can be built while the panels are generating, which uses more of your own power. Direct expansion runs when you milk, which is often outside the best of the solar day.
UpkeepEach refrigeration unit, pump and plate pack is one more thing to service. Ice banks can need more maintenance than other systems.

Any quote depends on what the site, the supply and your milk figures show. Ask for the running cost on your own tariff, not on an average one.

Which figures need measuring on your farm?

A design built on a guess at any of these can come out too small for the hot days or too costly for the rest. Each one can be measured or looked up before the design is settled.

The figures a cooling design rests on
FigureWhy a guess is not good enoughWhere it comes from
Litres in a milking at peakThe heat to take out rises with the volume.Your milk records, and your plans for the herd.
Milk temperature after the pre-cooler, in summerIt sets the temperature drop the refrigeration has to provide, and it is highest when the water is warmest.A reading at the cooler during a summer milking.
Length of milkingThe same heat in less time means a higher peak.Time a milking at peak, first cups on to last cups off.
What the supply can carry at milking timeA unit the supply cannot carry trips or struggles.A licensed electrician.
Other loads during milkingThey share the same supply.A list of what runs while you milk.
Tariff periods and chargesThey decide whether stored cooling saves money.Your electricity bill and your retailer.
When your solar generatesIt decides how much of a store can be built on your own power.Your inverter or monitoring app.
Where the condensing unit sitsHot, still air around a condenser cuts what the refrigeration can do.A look at the site: shade, open air, and room around it.

What should a glycol cooling proposal tell you?

A glycol proposal can mean a chiller that cools the milk as it flows, a glycol store built ahead, or a chiller that also cools the vat between milkings. Before you compare prices, check that each proposal answers these:

  • whether the glycol cools the milk on demand during milking, from a store, or both
  • the milk temperature into the vat it is designed for, at your peak milk flow and with your summer water
  • the compressor size, and the electrical load it adds at milking time
  • that the glycol is a food-grade mix
  • what cools and holds the milk in the vat between milkings: the chiller or the vat refrigeration
  • how the milk is kept cold if the chiller stops
  • whether heat recovery for wash water is included, and what water temperature it gives, which the guide to heat recovery from dairy refrigeration covers
  • who does each part: the refrigeration, the plate cooler and milk lines, and the electrical work

In one Victorian case study, a dairy at Tatura milking about 600 cows replaced its vat refrigeration with a 94 kW glycol chiller. It delivers milk to the vat at 2.5°C and cools the vat between milkings, and its heat goes to a heat recovery unit. Milk that had taken up to three hours after milking to reach its pick-up temperature now cools quickly, and compressor run times are shorter, but the chiller draws more power for a short time during milking. That is the trade an on-demand chiller makes.

Milk cooling and power worksheet

Milk cooling and power worksheet

Fill in what you know, then copy it or print it. Write "not known" for anything you would need someone to measure.

Your answers stay on this open page. They are not saved or sent. Copy or print them before you leave.

The milk

The cooling you have

Pre-cooling
Stored or on-demand cooling
Vat refrigeration once the milk is cold

Power

Power supply to the shed
The power has dipped or dropped out during milking
Peak or demand charge on the bill

The site

Where the condensing unit sits
Room beside the shed for an insulated tank
An old vat on the farm that could be reused

What you want to solve

Main reason for looking

Who does which part?

Vat refrigeration, chillers and ice banks are refrigeration work, and work that involves handling a scheduled refrigerant needs a technician licensed by the Australian Refrigeration Council (opens in a new tab). The plate cooler and the milk lines are usually the milking machine fitter's work, and any change to the power supply is for a licensed electrician. A proposal that crosses all three should say who does what.

ABL's refrigeration work includes milk vat cooling and bulk milk storage. Our farm and dairy refrigeration page explains how to book. Have your worksheet in front of you when you call.

Sources (11)

Weighing up a new milk cooling system?

Call ABL with your worksheet in front of you, or send an enquiry.

Filled in the record? Copy or print it first: it is not sent with a call or an enquiry.