Skip to the content

Comparing commercial air conditioning quotes line by line

Check commercial air conditioning offers price the same job, then compare controls, commissioning, warranty, upkeep and exclusions before the total.

Last updated

Compare what each offer will deliver before you compare the prices. First check that every contractor priced the same job: the same areas, hours, conditions and allowances. Then line the offers up on equipment, controls, commissioning, training, warranty and maintenance. List every exclusion and provisional item, ask each contractor the same questions in writing, and put a figure on anything one offer leaves out. Only then does the lowest total tell you which offer costs least.

How to use this guide

  1. Step 1: Check the basis

    The same areas, conditions, people and hours in every offer.

    Go to Same job
  2. Step 2: Line them up

    Line by line, with every exclusion given a figure.

    Go to Where offers differ
  3. Step 3: Fill in the worksheet

    Each offer's answer on the same line, so the gaps show.

    Go to the record

Did every contractor price the same job?

Commercial offers drift apart well before the price. One contractor allows for 20 people in the training room and another for 12. One designs to the indoor conditions in your brief and another to its own. One allows for the server room to run all night and another does not. Set each offer against your brief, and check:

  • the areas served, and any area an offer has missed
  • the indoor conditions each area is designed to hold, and the outdoor conditions the design assumes, because together they set the capacity
  • the people and the equipment allowed for in each area
  • the operating hours, including after hours and around the clock
  • the noise limits, indoors and at the boundary
  • the existing plant, ducts, pipes and controls each offer assumes it can keep

An offer built on a different basis is not wrong, but it is not the same job. Ask for the reason, and for a price on your basis as well. An alternative, such as a different type of system, can be the most useful idea you are offered. Take it alongside a price for what you asked for, with every departure from your brief listed and its effect on price, performance and timing. An item offered as "similar" or "equivalent" tells you nothing until you have the make and model.

Offers are far easier to compare when they answer the same brief. The guide to writing a commercial air conditioning project brief sets one out.

Where commercial offers differ

The guide to budgeting for a commercial air conditioning replacement lists the cost lines a quote should show. This table is about what to do when offers disagree. Read each line across all the offers before you move to the next.

Where commercial offers usually differ, and what to ask
LineWhere offers differAsk in writing for
EquipmentDifferent types of system, makes and capacities. One names its models and another says "or equivalent".The make, model and capacity of every unit, and how efficient it is at part load, where it spends most of its hours.
ControlsOne includes a central controller and the link to your building management system. Another stops at the wall controllers. Makers connect to a building management system in different ways: through a separate gateway, built into the central controller, or once a licence is activated.The interface and the protocol it uses, the points your system can read and set, any licence needed, and who programs your system's end of the link.
Commissioning"Commissioned to the maker's instructions" in one offer. Tests, balancing, a written report and a return visit in the opposite season in another.The tests, the records you will be given, and what has to pass before the job counts as finished. The guide to commercial commissioning and handover lists the documents.
TrainingA walk-through on the last day, or sessions for staff and for whoever maintains the system, with a record of who attended.Who is trained, on what, and when.
WarrantyEquipment only, or equipment and installation. Starting at delivery, or at completion. Conditional on servicing by the installer.The terms in writing, when they start, who they name, and what keeps them valid.
Defects and maintenanceThe defects period, the first service and a maintenance price included, or left out.Who attends to faults in the defects period, and the price of maintenance after it. The guide to commercial maintenance agreements covers what to compare.
ProgrammeLead times, start dates and how long each area is without air conditioning.A programme that shows each area's time without air conditioning.
Price basisA fixed price, a schedule of rates or a mix. GST included or not. How long the offer stands.Every figure with GST, the payment stages, and the date the offer lapses.

Exclusions to check before you compare totals

An exclusion is work the offer leaves out. The work does not go away: someone does it and you pay for it. Give each one a figure, from the contractor, another trade or your own estimate, and add it to that offer's total so the totals compare. These are the exclusions to look for on a commercial job:

Exclusions to look for, and what to ask
Often excludedWhat to ask
Electrical supply and switchboard workWhether the supply has been assessed, and by whom. Who does the work, at what price, and who pays if the supply needs upgrading. Some offers say "to the existing supply" without saying whether it will carry the load.
Builder's work, ceilings and making goodWho does the openings, roof penetrations and flashing, platforms and supports, who lifts and refits ceiling tiles and pays for damaged ones, and who patches, paints and cleans up afterwards. Whether the offer allows for working alongside the builder.
Fire separationWho seals pipes and ducts where they pass through fire-rated walls and floors, and who deals with any link to fire and smoke control. Schedule 8 of the Building Regulations 2018 (opens in a new tab), the list of essential safety measures, includes fire protection at service penetrations through fire-resisting elements, and air-handling systems under smoke hazard management.
Cranes, lifting and after-hours workThe lifting method, and whether the lift and the working hours you need are in the price.
Condensate drainageWhere each drain runs to, and who connects it.
Permits and approvalsWho finds out what the job needs, who applies, and who pays the fees.
AsbestosWho identifies it and deals with it before work starts. WorkSafe Victoria (opens in a new tab) says the person who manages or controls a workplace must identify asbestos likely to be disturbed before refurbishment work begins. Minor or routine maintenance work does not count as refurbishment.
Removing the old plantWhether recovering the refrigerant, removing the plant and disposing of it are all in the price.
Temporary coolingWhether any is included for the areas that will be without air conditioning, and for how long.

A provisional sum is different from an exclusion. It is an allowance inside the total, and the budget guide explains how it works. Compare offers by putting the same allowance against the same item in each. Check that every provisional sum says what it covers, so the same work is not also in the fixed price, and read how each offer treats an overrun.

Ask every contractor the same questions, in writing

Keep one list of questions for the whole comparison. Send each question to every contractor in the same words, and get every answer in writing. Where an answer changes an offer, ask for the change to be shown as a change, and make the written answers part of the offer you accept. Two habits keep the comparison fair: do not pass one contractor's ideas or prices to another, and if you let one contractor correct an error or revise its offer, give every contractor the same chance.

Warranty, consumer guarantees and the defects period

Compare each warranty as written in the offer, not as described on the phone: what it covers, when it starts, who it names, and what keeps it valid, such as servicing on schedule.

As at November 2026, section 3 of the Australian Consumer Law (opens in a new tab) treats a business as a consumer for goods or services whose price did not exceed $100,000 including GST (the amount set by regulation for purchases from 1 July 2021), or that are of a kind ordinarily bought for personal, domestic or household use. For goods, that does not apply where they were bought to resupply, or to use up or transform in production or manufacture, or in repairing or treating other goods or fixtures on land. A warranty against defects is in addition to the consumer guarantees and does not limit or replace them. A large commercial installation can sit above the threshold, which makes the written warranty and the contract terms matter all the more. Where one contract covers both the equipment and its installation, ask the supplier or a legal adviser to confirm how the threshold applies to your job.

Larger jobs are usually done under a formal contract with a defects liability period, starting at practical completion, during which the contractor must put right defects at its own cost. Government standard forms often default to 12 months, but the contract sets it. Some contracts also hold security, such as a share of the price retained, with part returned at practical completion and the rest when the period ends. A smaller job done on an accepted quote may have no defects period at all, so ask each contractor to write down how long it will come back to fix defects. Compare the period, its start and any security in each offer.

Check who will do the work

  • Refrigerant. Check each technician's licence on the Australian Refrigeration Council's Look for the tick (opens in a new tab) site, by licence number and surname. The result shows the licence type, and the Council says a licence is not a warranty of the quality of the work. Check that the type covers the job: the restricted split system licence (RSS03) covers installing and decommissioning a single-head split system of less than 18 kW only, so it does not cover servicing, or a multi-head or VRF system. On a commercial job, look for the full refrigeration and air conditioning licence (opens in a new tab) (RAC01).
  • Electrical. Energy Safe Victoria (opens in a new tab) says electrical installation work needs a registered electrical contractor, that you should ask to see a tradesperson's licence, and that a Certificate of Electrical Safety is given for completed electrical installation work. A restricted electrical worker's licence (opens in a new tab) allows like-for-like disconnecting and reconnecting only.
  • Plumbing. In Victoria, refrigerated air-conditioning work is a class of plumbing work under regulation 23 of the Plumbing Regulations 2018 (opens in a new tab). Ask for the plumbing licence or registration of whoever will do it, and check its class. The Building and Plumbing Commission's restricted class (opens in a new tab) covers installing and commissioning a single-head split system up to 18 kW cooling capacity, a ceiling cassette system, or an add-on condenser unit for a ducted system, and no other mechanical services work.
  • Subcontractors. Which parts of the work are subcontracted, to whom, and who signs for each part.
  • Insurance. The insurance each party holds, written into the contract, and cover that suits what the contractor could be liable for on your job.
  • Your own duties. Engaging a contractor does not hand over your safety duties. WorkSafe Victoria (opens in a new tab) says an employer has the same duty to protect the health and safety of contractors working in its workplace as it has to its own employees, for matters it controls. Safe access to your roof is one of them.

Price over the life of the system

The lowest price and value for money are different things. Compare the offers over the years the system will run: the purchase, the energy, the maintenance and the repairs. Two things to watch:

  • Energy estimates rest on assumptions. Ask each contractor for the operating hours, the loads and the tariff it assumed, and use the same ones for every offer. Commercial electricity tariffs vary with time of day and demand, so a yearly total multiplied by one price per kilowatt hour can mislead.
  • Maintenance moves the life-cycle cost. Good maintenance usually extends equipment life and cuts downtime and energy use. A system that is cheaper to buy but harder to reach and maintain can cost more over its life.

Commercial quote comparison worksheet

Commercial air conditioning quote comparison

Write every offer's answer on the same line, for example "A: included. B: excluded. C: not stated." Put each "not stated" on your list of questions.

Your answers stay on this open page. They are not saved or sent. Copy or print them before you leave.

The offers

The same job

Line by line

The price

The decision

Who to call

ABL installs, replaces and maintains air conditioning for businesses in Bairnsdale and East Gippsland, and we look at the site before we quote. Our commercial air conditioning page covers the service, and the enquiry form is on our air conditioning services page. As at November 2026, ABL offers a free site assessment and a free quote. Send your brief with the enquiry.

Sources (29)

Comparing offers for a commercial job?

Send ABL your brief with an enquiry to get a quote on the same basis, or call to talk it through.

Filled in the record? Copy or print it first: it is not sent with a call or an enquiry.