Repair or replace a commercial air conditioning system: how to decide
How to decide between repairing and replacing a commercial air conditioning system: the signs, the questions to ask, and a decision record to fill in.
Last updated
Repair a commercial air conditioner when the fault is a one-off, the parts are available and the system still suits the building. Plan a replacement when faults keep coming back, the repair is a large share of the price of a new system, parts or refrigerant are getting hard to find, or the building has outgrown what the system was designed for. Age alone does not decide it. The decision record in this guide puts the repair and the replacement side by side on the same lines.
How to use this guide
Step 2: Fill in the record
Put the repair and the replacement on the same lines, with the cost of downtime.
Go to the record
When is repair the better choice, and when is replacement?
A common starting point is the half rule: when a repair costs more than about half the installed price of a new system, look hard at replacing. For a business it is only a start. It leaves out what downtime costs you, the work a replacement needs around the equipment, and how much life the rest of the system has left. These are the signs we weigh.
| What you see | Points toward | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A first fault on a system that has been reliable | Repair | One failed part does not mean the others are close behind. |
| The same fault back again, or call-outs getting closer together | Replacement | Reliability is falling. Each repair buys less time than the one before, and each failure costs you trade or comfort. |
| A small part has failed | Repair | A sensor, a drain pump or a fan motor is a modest job on a system that is otherwise sound. |
| A major part has failed in an old system | Replacement | A new compressor or coil is a large share of the price of a new system, and it goes into equipment whose other parts are the same age. |
| The system is losing refrigerant | It depends on where the leak is | Refrigerant is not used up, so a low charge means a leak. A leak at a joint can be repaired. A leak in a corroded coil means a new coil, which is a major part. |
| Parts are no longer made for it | Replacement | A repair that waits weeks for a part, or relies on a second-hand one, leaves you exposed the next time. |
| The building has changed | Replacement, or a redesign | More people, more equipment or a new layout can leave a sound system the wrong size or in the wrong place. The guide to air conditioning checks before a fitout or change of use covers this. |
| It runs, and costs more to run each year | Plan a replacement | New equipment is generally more efficient. A system that still works gives you time to replace it in a season and a window that suit the business. |
How long does a commercial air conditioner last?
About 15 years is the middle figure for commercial split, ducted and rooftop units: about half have been replaced by that age. Whole commercial systems are commonly planned on a life of 20 to 25 years, and ductwork outlasts the units it serves. Salt air near the coast shortens the life of outdoor units, and so does going without servicing.
So treat age as a prompt to plan, not as a reason to replace. At about ten years, start keeping the history this guide asks for and put a replacement in the forward budget. Because ducts outlast the units, a replacement can often keep sound ductwork and renew the equipment, which changes the price.
Servicing is part of the same picture. WorkSafe Victoria's compliance code for workplace facilities and the working environment (opens in a new tab) says all heating and cooling facilities need to be serviced regularly and kept in proper working order. We recommend a service at least once a year, and twice a year for a commercial system that runs daily or a site near the coast.
Does the type of refrigerant force a replacement?
Neither the phase-out of R22 nor the phase-down of the refrigerants that followed it requires you to replace a working system. What changes is how easy and how costly a repair to the refrigerant circuit will be. The nameplate on the outdoor unit says which refrigerant the system uses.
The oldest systems still running use R22. The Australian Refrigeration Council's fact sheet on R22 (opens in a new tab), dated July 2026, says existing R22 equipment is not banned, does not need to be decommissioned and can continue to be serviced. It also says imports of R22 will be banned entirely from 1 January 2030, after which servicing will rely on recycled or reclaimed gas, that the price may rise with demand and availability, and that spare parts might become harder to source. For an R22 system, a fault in the refrigerant circuit is a strong reason to plan the replacement.
Newer systems use hydrofluorocarbon refrigerants. As at November 2026, the Australian Government's phase-down of those refrigerants (opens in a new tab) reduces bulk imports over time and does not affect existing equipment, so it is not a reason to take out a system that works.
Whatever the refrigerant, a leak has to be dealt with properly. The Australian Refrigeration Council says it is illegal to recharge a system before its leaks are tested and repaired (opens in a new tab), so a repair quote for a system that is low on refrigerant covers finding and repairing the leak, not just the gas.
What to record about the history of the system
The decision is only as good as the history behind it. Pull this together before you ask anyone for a recommendation:
- The nameplate. Brand, model, serial number and refrigerant, from the plate on the outdoor unit, and the year it was installed if you know it.
- Each fault. The date, what the system did, what was found and what was done about it.
- Each call-out. How many in the last 12 months and the last three years, and what they cost.
- Servicing. When it was last serviced, how often, and by whom.
- Parts. Any repair that waited on a part, and for how long.
- What downtime did. Trade lost, rooms closed, staff moved or sent home, stock or equipment at risk, and complaints from customers or tenants.
The last item is the one most often left out, and for a business it can outweigh the repair bill. Put a rough figure on a day without the system, even if it is only an estimate. The guide to commercial air conditioning asset registers covers keeping these records as you go.
Questions to ask about a service recommendation
Whether the recommendation is a repair or a replacement, you are entitled to understand it before you approve it. These questions are fair to ask any contractor, us included.
| Ask | A good answer includes |
|---|---|
| What did you find, and how? | The fault code, the readings taken and photos of the part. A finding you can be shown is easier to trust than one you are told. |
| What caused it? | The reason the part failed, not only which part. A part that failed because of a blocked coil or a poor power supply will fail again if only the part is changed. |
| What else is close to failing? | The condition of the rest of the system: coils, fans, electrical parts, drains and the cabinet of the outdoor unit. |
| Is the part available, and for how long? | The wait for this part, and whether the maker still supports the model. |
| What are my options? | More than one: a repair, a repair now with a replacement planned, a part replacement, a full replacement. Each with a price and what it leaves unsolved. |
| What happens if I wait? | What the system is likely to do in the meantime, and what a failure in the busy season would cost against acting now. |
| What does the price include? | Parts, labour, refrigerant, any return visit, and the warranty on the work, in writing. |
| Can I have that in writing? | A short report with the findings, the photos and the options, so the decision can be made by people who were not on site. |
If two contractors disagree, compare their evidence, not their confidence. The one who can show you the readings and the failed part has given you something to check.
Compare the whole cost of each option
A repair quote and a replacement quote are not the same kind of number. Line them up like this before you compare them.
| Line | Repair | Replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Price today | The repair quote. | The whole installed price: equipment, electrical work, access, building work, removal and commissioning. The guide to budgeting for a commercial air conditioning replacement lists every line. |
| What is uncertain | Whether the repair holds, and what the next failure will be. | The provisional items in the quote, and what the building hides. |
| Time without air conditioning | The wait for parts, plus the repair. Unplanned, and often in the busy season. | The changeover. Planned, in a window you choose. See the guide to replacing commercial air conditioning while the business stays open. |
| Repairs to come | The other parts are as old as the one that failed. | Whatever the warranty in the quote covers, for its term. |
| Running cost | Unchanged. | Usually lower, by an amount that depends on the old system and the hours it runs. |
| Parts and refrigerant | Harder to get as the model ages. | Current. |
| What you have afterwards | The same system, with one newer part. | A new system, sized for the building as it is used now. |
There is often a middle course. Where a building has several independent systems, replacing the worst one and repairing the others is a sound plan. Within one system, the indoor and outdoor units are a matched set, so a new outdoor unit usually means new indoor units as well, while sound ductwork can often stay. And a repair that gets a tired system through summer can be the right call if it buys a replacement in autumn, in a window that suits you.
Repair or replace decision record
If the system has already failed
A failed system is a repair call first and a decision second. The refrigerant handling code of practice (opens in a new tab) tells owners that a malfunctioning unit should be seen by a competent service technician as soon as the problem appears. Our air conditioning repairs page explains how to book a fault. Once you know what has failed and what the repair costs, fill in the decision record before you approve anything large.
ABL repairs, services and replaces air conditioning for businesses in Bairnsdale and East Gippsland. Our commercial air conditioning page covers the service, and the enquiry form is on our air conditioning services page.
Sources (8)
- ASHRAE: economic analyses and life-cycle costs, with equipment service life tables (opens in a new tab) Checked on 19 November 2026.
- Australian Government, energy.gov.au: HVAC equipment guide for business (opens in a new tab) Checked on 19 November 2026.
- Australian Refrigeration Council: fact sheet 26, R22 gas and equipment, July 2026 (opens in a new tab) Checked on 19 November 2026.
- Australian Government: hydrofluorocarbon phase-down, updated 4 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) Checked on 17 November 2026.
- Australian Refrigeration Council: fact sheet 13, refrigerant leaks, July 2026 (opens in a new tab) Checked on 17 November 2026.
- Australia and New Zealand refrigerant handling code of practice, part 2, 2025 edition (opens in a new tab) Checked on 19 November 2026.
- WorkSafe Victoria: compliance code, Workplace facilities and the working environment, December 2023 (opens in a new tab) Checked on 19 November 2026.
- ABL Refrigeration: air conditioning services (opens in a new tab) ABL's own page. Checked on 19 November 2026.
Related pages
- Commercial air conditioning replacement budget: what to allow
Every line of the replacement side of the comparison.
- Commercial air conditioning replacement in an occupied building
How a planned replacement is staged around a business that stays open.
- Commercial AC asset registers and the records to retain
How to keep the fault and service history this decision relies on.
Weighing a repair against a replacement?
Call ABL with your decision record, or send an enquiry and we will look at the system.
Filled in the record? Copy or print it first: it is not sent with a call or an enquiry.
